Crumbl’s Monster Cookie Review
Today I’m sharing my review of Crumbl’s Monster Cookie. Like a classic Monster cookie, the cookie is thick and chewy and packed with mix-ins. It’s a chewy cookie that’s got peanut butter, chocolate candies, chunks of chocolate, and oatmeal. Mm!
Hey Crumbl fans! I have started adding these lightning-fast reviews to my website as a place to share my thoughts on the different Crumbl Cookies I’ve tried. I’d love to add your feedback too, so feel free to drop a comment! ~Ellen
Crumbl Cookies might be known for some of their more outrageous flavors, but their simpler options are tasty too. Monster cookies are a lunchbox classic with a host of tasty mix-ins. Crumbl’s version is huge (of course) and filled with chocolate and peanut butter flavor.
Crumbl describes the cookie as packed with “peanut butter, chocolate candies, semi-sweet chocolate chunks, brown sugar, and oatmeal”.
My Review of Crumbl’s Monster Cookie
The cookie is quite large and thick–just like you would expect from a Crumbl cookie! I thought it had a good amount of chewiness. The oatmeal and peanut butter in the base were perfect.
This is cookie that is best on day 1. Once it starts to dry out it is not as tasty. Bonus points if it’s still warm when you get it from Crumbl!
The cookie had a pretty good amount of mix-ins, but I think it actually should’ve had just a little more chocolate–maybe more chocolate-covered candies?
Don’t forget: you can store this cookie at room temperature in an air-tight container for a few days, but I think it’s best when it’s warm and fresh on day one.
The Verdict
Would I buy it again? This isn’t one of my top Crumbl Cookies, but it’s pretty good and I would buy it again if I needed to fill out a 4-pack or 6-pack box.
I actually would really like to make a copycat version of this recipe, because in my mind it’s the perfect example of a what a Monster cookie should be–huge and totally packed with tasty chocolate pieces! Yum.
Tip: If you like Crumbl Cookies, try my recent copycat recipe for their Milk Chocolate Chip cookie–mmmm, so good! Also visit my Past Menus page to check out the weekly Crumbl menus for the current week and past weeks!
